Managing Frustration When Something Keeps Blocking You
Frustration is the feeling of a goal being blocked, so the useful first question is whether you can remove the block. Venting, hitting things or replaying the problem tends to keep anger high: a meta-analysis of 154 studies found arousal-lowering activities reduced anger and aggression while arousal-raising ones did not. Calm down first, then either fix the block or, if it truly cannot be fixed, change how you read it.
Editorially checked
Explore your emotions and relationships with the free EQTiger assessment.
By EQTiger Editorial. Published .
Reviewed by: pending qualified review
Frustration is a signal about a blocked goal
You are trying to get somewhere, and something is in the way. The printer jams on the one page you need. The insurance phone tree loops you back to the main menu. Your teenager says “I'll do it later” for the fourth time. Your code passes every test but one. The feeling that rises is frustration, and it usually comes with heat: a clenched jaw, a sharper voice, the urge to hit the keyboard.
Treating frustration as a signal rather than a problem changes the next move. The signal says: a goal you care about is blocked. That leaves two real questions. Can the block be removed? And is your body too wound up right now to remove it well?
The punching-bag experiment
A popular idea says anger builds up like steam and needs releasing: scream into a pillow, hit a punching bag, “get it out.” Brad Bushman tested this directly. He angered 600 undergraduates with harsh written comments on an essay they had just written, then had some hit a punching bag while thinking about the person who angered them, some hit it while thinking about getting fit, and some sit quietly. Those who hit the bag while focused on the person ended up the angriest and the most aggressive when given a chance to blast that person with noise. Doing nothing worked better than venting. (Bushman, 2002)
Two decades later, Sophie Kjærvik and Bushman pooled 154 studies with 10,189 participants. Activities that lower arousal, such as slow breathing, relaxation and mindfulness, reduced anger and aggression (g = -0.63). Activities that raise arousal, such as hitting a bag, jogging or cycling, had no overall effect (g = -0.02). (Kjærvik and Bushman, 2024) The practical lesson: “turn down the heat” beats “let off steam.” A run is still good for you; it is just not an anger tool.
| Move | Effect on arousal | What the evidence suggests | Better use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hitting a pillow or punching bag | Raises it | Kept anger high in experiments | Skip it as an anger tool |
| Ranting about the person, over and over | Keeps it high | Rumination prolongs anger and low mood | One short telling, then a plan |
| Going for a run while replaying it | Raises it | No average effect on anger | Exercise later, for its own sake |
| Slow breathing or muscle relaxation | Lowers it | Reduced anger across many studies | First five minutes |
| Stepping away to something absorbing | Lowers it | Distraction helps in the short term | When the block cannot be fixed today |
| Fixing the block directly | Varies | Best when the problem is controllable | After you have calmed down enough to think |
Sort the block: fixable, partly fixable or not fixable
Once the heat has come down a notch, sort the block. Allison Troy and colleagues found that in 170 adults, people good at reframing had lower depression when their stress was uncontrollable, but higher depression when it was controllable, perhaps because they accepted things they could have changed. (Troy, Shallcross, and Mauss, 2013) Frustration is the same. Reframing a fixable problem just leaves it in place.
- Fixable: the jammed printer, the unclear assignment, the recurring fight over dishes. Act. Clear the jam, ask the one question, propose a rota.
- Partly fixable: a slow bureaucracy, a colleague who is often late. Change what you can (book the first appointment of the day, start the meeting without them) and reframe the rest.
- Not fixable today: a canceled flight, a rejection already sent. Lower arousal, distract with a return time, then reframe: “This cost me a day. It does not cost me the trip.”
Watch for the replay loop
Frustration often outlives the event because the mind replays it: what they said, what you should have said, how unfair it was. Susan Nolen-Hoeksema and colleagues' review of rumination concluded that this kind of repetitive dwelling worsens mood, makes thinking more negative and impairs problem solving. (Nolen-Hoeksema, Wisco, and Lyubomirsky, 2008) A quick test: if you have gone over the same frustration three times and have not added a new fact or a new option, you are looping, not solving. Write the next action on paper and switch to something else.
The insurance claim that would not go through
Marcus spent forty minutes on hold, was transferred twice and was disconnected. His first impulse was to call back immediately and tell the next agent exactly what he thought of the company. Instead he stood up, did two minutes of slow breathing with long exhales, and wrote three lines: claim number, what he needed (a reference for the denied claim), and the one question to ask (“What document do you need from me to reopen it?”).
He called back the next morning at 8:01, when the hold time was shorter, asked the question, and got an email address for the document. The company did not get any easier to deal with. The call took twelve minutes instead of forty, and he did not spend the evening retelling it.
The three-attempt rule for repeated frustration
- When something blocks you, try your normal approach once more, calmly and deliberately.
- If it fails again, change one variable for attempt two: a different time, channel, person or wording.
- If attempt two fails, stop and lower your arousal for five minutes (slow breathing, a short walk at an easy pace, or something absorbing).
- For attempt three, ask for help or escalate with a specific request, such as “Who can approve this?” or “Can you show me how you'd do it?”
- If attempt three fails, decide whether the goal is worth more effort today. If not, write the next step and the date you will try it, and let it rest.
When frustration keeps coming from the same place
If the same source frustrates you every week, such as a process at work, a pattern with a family member or a commute, it is usually a setup problem rather than a feelings problem. The guide to emotional regulation at work covers workplace patterns, and responding instead of reacting shows how to write an if-then plan for a trigger you can predict.
Frustration that tips into rage, frightens people around you, or leads to breaking things is worth raising with a licensed professional. If someone in your life responds to frustration with threats or violence toward you, that is not a regulation problem for you to solve: contact the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233, text START to 88788, or visit thehotline.org, and call emergency services if you are in danger.
For low-stakes practice, the everyday exercises use exactly these kinds of small blocks as training. The techniques comparison sets out the wider evidence, and the emotional regulation hub has the full series.
Key takeaways
- Frustration signals a blocked goal; ask whether the block can be removed.
- Venting and hitting things keep anger high; calming activities lower it.
- Lower your arousal first, then fix what is fixable and reframe only what is not.
- Three replays without a new fact or option means you are looping, not solving.
Use the free EQTiger assessment to choose a starting point for reflection. Read what the assessment includes and the limitations before interpreting your result.
Research notes
Bushman, 2002: Angered participants who hit a punching bag while thinking about the person who angered them ended up angrier and more aggressive than those who hit it while thinking about fitness or who did nothing, and doing nothing beat venting.
Brad J. Bushman (2002). Does Venting Anger Feed or Extinguish the Flame? Catharsis, Rumination, Distraction, Anger, and Aggressive Responding. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. doi.org/10.1177/0146167202289002
Kjærvik and Bushman, 2024: Across 154 studies with 10,189 participants, arousal-lowering activities such as slow breathing and relaxation reduced anger and aggression (g = -0.63), while arousal-raising activities such as hitting a bag or jogging had no overall effect (g = -0.02).
Sophie L. Kjærvik, Brad J. Bushman (2024). A meta-analytic review of anger management activities that increase or decrease arousal: What fuels or douses rage?. Clinical Psychology Review. doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2024.102414
Nolen-Hoeksema, Wisco, and Lyubomirsky, 2008: This review concludes that repetitively dwelling on distress worsens low mood, sharpens negative thinking, impairs problem solving and erodes social support, and that dozens of experiments show positive distraction relieves low mood in the short term.
Susan Nolen-Hoeksema, Blair E. Wisco, Sonja Lyubomirsky (2008). Rethinking Rumination. Perspectives on Psychological Science. doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-6924.2008.00088.x
Troy, Shallcross, and Mauss, 2013: In 170 adults, better reappraisal ability went with lower depression when recent stress was uncontrollable but with higher depression when the stress was controllable, suggesting reframing fits problems you cannot change better than ones you can.
Allison S. Troy, Amanda J. Shallcross, Iris B. Mauss (2013). A person-by-situation approach to emotion regulation: Cognitive reappraisal can either help or hurt, depending on the context. Psychological Science. doi.org/10.1177/0956797613496434
2 questions
Questions
Is it healthy to vent frustration?
Venting by hitting things or ranting while focused on the person who frustrated you tends to keep anger high rather than release it. Talking a problem through to plan what to do is different from rehearsing the grievance.
Does exercise help with anger?
Exercise is good for health, but in a large meta-analysis, arousal-raising activities like jogging did not reduce anger on average. Calming activities such as slow breathing and relaxation did.
Related
- No. 01Everyday Emotional Regulation Exercises for One Ordinary WeekThe easiest way to build regulation skill is to practice on small daily annoyances, a slow checkout line or a passive-aggressive group chat, rather than waiting for a big fight. This seven-day plan uses one short exercise per day: naming the feeling, slow breathing, self-talk by name, changing a setup, reframing, timed distraction and a weekly review. Evidence for each is real but modest, and most of it comes from short lab studies.
- No. 02Emotional Regulation Techniques, Compared by EvidenceThe best-supported emotional regulation techniques change how you read a situation (reappraisal and perspective taking) or move your attention elsewhere for a while (distraction), while dwelling on the feeling and trying not to feel it tend to backfire. In the largest meta-analysis of lab experiments, perspective taking had the biggest effect and reappraising the situation a small-to-medium one. No technique wins everywhere: reframing suits problems you cannot change, and problems you can change usually need action.
- No. 03How to Respond Instead of React, One If-Then Plan at a TimeTo respond instead of react, decide in advance what you will do when a specific trigger happens, in the form “If X happens, then I will do Y,” and rehearse the first sentence you will say. If-then plans had a medium-to-large effect on reaching goals across 94 tests, and in lab studies they reduced fear and disgust reactions where a goal alone did not. Talking to yourself by name and naming the feeling can widen the gap further.
- No. 04Emotional Regulation at Work: Managing Feelings You Cannot Always ShowAt work, faking a feeling you do not have (surface acting) is consistently linked with exhaustion and lower job satisfaction, while trying to actually see the situation differently (deep acting) has weak links to strain and better links to customer satisfaction. Combine deep acting during the shift with real breaks and mentally switching off afterward. When the emotional load comes from understaffing or abusive customers, that is a job design problem to raise, not a personal regulation failure.
Your next 9 minutes
Understand your emotions.
36 questions about everyday moments. A fresh starting point for reflection.
Free to take. Full report $6.95. One-time payment. No subscription.